Galactic Civilizations 4 review


Galactic Civilizations 4 bills itself as the most accessible game in the series. This is true, in the same way that the tail is the most accessible part of a tiger. Stardock's long running 4X series officially has a tutorial now, in the form of a little robot helper accursedly nicknamed 'Space Clippy.' But Space Clippy doesn't help much when a game explains everything as if it's arrived from another dimension.

Need to Know

What is it? Colourful, deep space 4X game
Expect to pay: £39.99
Developer: Stardock
Publisher: Stardock
Reviewed on: AMD Ryzen 5 3600, Nvidia GeForce 2080 Super, 32 GB RAM,
Multiplayer: Yes
Link: GalCiv4.com

Take modules as an example. What are modules, you ask? Well, so did I. At first I thought modules were optional extras you could select to tailor your starbases (which act as both resource harvesters and deployable control points, with modules helping improve those functions in various ways). But then I ran out of modules, whereupon I realised they are in fact a consumable resource.  Yet unlike almost every other resource in the game, which are either harvested in space or produced on planets, modules are constructed at shipyards.

Oh, and you can only construct modules once you've researched the relevant technology, another issue I'll get into later.

As with many other systems, GalCiv never properly explains any of this. Space Clippy just points you to various menus like a dismissive waiter in an alien restaurant. The irony is GalCiv 4 is not as obtuse as it seems. It's just terrible at communicating, which means enjoying the game at its best involves a lot of false starts.

Space… is big

This isn't merely about understanding individual systems: it's also about how key features are presented. Take the game's biggest new idea, sectors. Rather than display its universe as one vast expanse of stars, GalCiv 4 splits the cosmos into self-contained bubbles, connected to one another by subspace warps (aka space roads). You can play on randomly generated maps with around a dozen of these bubbles, each of which has roughly 30 stars in it. 

This lets Stardock proclaim GalCiv 4 the largest game in the series ever. Yet while visually impressive, playing at this scale isn't all that fun. 'Galactic' size games are painfully slow, while ship management becomes extremely fiddly as you're constantly having to zoom in and out to issue orders to individual fleets. GalCiv is more fun on smaller maps. Not only does the game move faster with empires forced to rub shoulders more, but the strategic importance of sectors becomes more acute, as those space roads connecting them turn into highways that can be monitored (although not completely blockaded) to help defend your empire.

Image 1 of 6

Galactic Civilizations 4

As well as the premade factions, you can create your own, including evil squirrels known as Snathi. (Image credit: Stardock)
Image 2 of 6

Galactic Civilizations 4

Imagine if E.T. got into crypto. (Image credit: Stardock)
Image 3 of 6

Galactic Civilizations 4

Your circle of influence expands over time. (Image credit: Stardock)
Image 4 of 6

Galactic Civilizations 4

ore worlds can be improved with buildings. (Image credit: Stardock)
Image 5 of 6

Galactic Civilizations 4

Combat is resolved automatically, but you can watch replays of your fleets in action. (Image credit: Stardock)
Image 6 of 6

Galactic Civilizations 4

Optional side-missions will crop up from time to time, offering rewards like prototype ships. (Image credit: Stardock)

Not that keeping invaders out will guarantee victory. GalCiv 4 introduces a new victory condition called “Prestige”. This tracks how awesome your empire is in a wide range of categories, awarding you Prestige points to reflect how good your military or research or tourism industry is. Gain sufficient prestige points, and you win the game. This helps facilitate nonviolent victories and prevent larger-scale maps from descending into wars of attrition. You can also gain Prestige bonuses by completing a range of quests that replace the standard campaign of previous games, unlocking as your civilization meets certain criteria. This lets you experience the “story” of GalCiv 4 without being forced to play as a specific faction.

Deep thought

GalCiv 4 just doesn’t have much of a hook compared to other space 4X games

Those welcome additions are accompanied by the distinction between colonies and core worlds. Core worlds are planets managed by you directly. You'll assign a governor to them, construct productivity-boosting buildings on them, and have the option to build a starbase nearby. Colonies, on the other hand, require no direct management, simply funnelling their resources to the nearest core world.

The idea is to reduce your management duties from upward of a hundred planets to perhaps a dozen or two. And it works—or at least, it does once you've figured out how to effectively differentiate between colonies and core worlds. A colony becomes a core world when you assign a governor to it, so functionally it's up to you to decide. But only worlds with “Excellent” ratings or above are worth turning into core worlds. Since the game doesn't tell you this, it's easy to rush into colonising a bunch of barely habitable backwaters while the AI nicks all the good planets from under your nose, snout, or proboscis.  

The “proper” way to establish core worlds is slow and involved, and you may find yourself more inclined to direct intervention. Conquering other empires is mechanically straightforward: you just click on a fleet or planet to attack it, then wait until the battle or siege is resolved. Again though, GalCiv fails to mention that core worlds can only be conquered after researching a specific technology called Planetary Invasion. Colonies, on the other hand, can be snatched at any time with any ship, even a lone starfighter. This goes too far the other way, with wars descending into glorified pest control unless you ensure all colonies have a couple of ships stationed to defend them.

Don't panic

Image 1 of 7

Galactic Civilizations 4

Landing on planets will sometimes result in a story-based dilemma, although resolving them is mostly about which reward you want. (Image credit: Stardock)
Image 2 of 7

Galactic Civilizations 4

Resources are harvested via starbases. (Image credit: Stardock)
Image 3 of 7

Galactic Civilizations 4

Colonies can be sieged with a single starfighter, which is a bit silly. (Image credit: Stardock)
Image 4 of 7

Galactic Civilizations 4

“Hi I’m the Festron Hunt. You might remember me from such films as ‘John Carpenter’s The Thing.'” (Image credit: Stardock)
Image 5 of 7

Galactic Civilizations 4

Massive maps look cool, but the game is better when space is at a premium. (Image credit: Stardock)
Image 6 of 7

Galactic Civilizations 4

The array of ship designs is impressive, and you can even make your own. (Image credit: Stardock)
Image 7 of 7

Galactic Civilizations 4

‘Leaders’ perform all manner of jobs, from governing your worlds to commanding flagships. (Image credit: Stardock)

Once you've parsed GalCiv's garbled attempts to communicate with you the universe feels sufficiently weird and ripe with possibility for a sprawling sci-fi sandbox. Not just in the various races you encounter, which range from fleshly mantis-like creatures who thrive on oceanic worlds, to armies of sentient robots who don't need food to survive, but also in the many anomalies that you can scan for minor rewards, such as ships you can patch up from wreck sites, or strange artifacts that provide you with one-off powers.

As your empire develops you'll unlock a range of “executive orders”, special edicts that can instantly recruit a new colony ship, boost your income, or reveal a new system on the map. In a game where progress is highly gradual, these quickfire bonuses offer a satisfying immediacy. In one instance I used an artifact to give a colony ship an extra move, helping it evade a fleet of pirates and beat a rival vessel to the best planet in the sector.

As the game unfolds your avenues of approach become more varied. Diplomacy, for example, initially seems limited, and it's difficult to get anything resembling a decent deal from other factions. As you gain access to better diplomacy tech your options for forming different relationships and alliances expand considerably. There are still issues though, like enemies who sue for peace during a war while refusing to offer any incentives for you to stop.

So long… 

Indeed, while most of GalCiv's “problems” stem from poor onboarding, there are a few other black holes visible amid the background glow of competence. By far the biggest is research. GalCiv's tech tree is more of a tech arboretum, so to make decisions easier, the game presents you with several new techs, pruned semi-randomly from the tree, to pick from as your next research project. This works fine until you actively want to pursue a specific tech, like say, the Planetary Invasion system I mentioned earlier, which is an important mechanic to leave to the whims of chance.

You can trade tech with other races—which is how I eventually got it—but they have to be willing to trade it with you, a situation by no means guaranteed.

Image 1 of 6

Galactic Civilizations 4

Just don’t call it a Furby. (Image credit: Stardock)
Image 2 of 6

Galactic Civilizations 4

There are special events for colonising your most local worlds. (Image credit: Stardock)
Image 3 of 6

Galactic Civilizations 4

Research gives you a random selection of tech to choose from. Which can be problematic. (Image credit: Stardock)
Image 4 of 6

Galactic Civilizations 4

Other races will randomly contact you with bits of lore, a bit like your grandad calling up for a chat. (Image credit: Stardock)
Image 5 of 6

Galactic Civilizations 4

It’s important to keep planet governors on side, or they might govern your planet for someone else. (Image credit: Stardock)
Image 6 of 6

Galactic Civilizations 4

Unlike Crusader Kings, decisions rarely have follow-up consequences. (Image credit: Stardock)

More broadly, GalCiv 4 just doesn't have much of a hook compared to other space 4X games. There's little here you haven’t seen done better in, say, Stellaris, such as the nuggets of narrative tied to anomalies. Other new features, such as the Crusader Kings-style relationship you have with Governors and Citizens, are highly simplistic, basically meaning that a planet might abandon you for another faction if you let the Governor's opinion of you drop too low. The ship editor is nice, going well with GalCiv's general visual snazziness. But it's very much an auxiliary feature, with little meaningful impact.

Galactic Civilizations 4 is like an ancient alien race awakening to find a bunch of pioneering little upstarts have hit the scene, all buzzing around with their hot new spaceships and innovative ideas. Its response to this is to go big, but it's also broad and conservative. Space Clippy represents a token effort to make contact, but Galactic Civilizations 4 ultimately doesn't really care if the message is understood.

It's got a legacy spanning decades, disciples in their thousands and a formula for space exploration that's worked since time immemorial. It doesn't need your approval. It's GalCiv.